- 1974 Capital Publishing Co. #5
- AstrosFreakCam #9
- 1948 R346 #12
- 1953 Topps #20
- DodgerBobble #21
- CubsFan #23
- AdamE #40
- Don WO #41
- Mark #44
- Mark A and 1971 Topps #55
- 1934 Batter-Up #61
- Chris S #69
- Fuji #72
- Greg Z #75
- Hackenbush #80
- 1933 Goudey #95
- Beardy #99
- Mariner1 #105
- 1971 Topps #110
- 1955 Topps #116
- TiedGame #117
- Nathan #124
- 1941 Play Ball #128
- Matt Hicks #133
- 1953 Bowman Color #137
- PlayAtThePlate #142
- Captain Canuck #167
- Andrew #175
- BA Benny #177
- 1962 Post Cereal #181
- Night Owl #192
- 1962 Topps #197
Congrats to Mark A, the only exact match, who picks up a 1971 Topps #55 Steve Carlton! Here's the full list of winners, judged by numerical proximity.
- AstrosFreakCam: 1974 Capital Publishing #5 Roger Connor (StL) and 1948 R346 #12 Phil Masi (Boston Braves)
- DodgerBobble: 1953 Topps #20 Hank Thompson (uh oh, it's a NY Giant :-)
- Mark A: 1971 Topps #55 Carlton (Cardinals) and 1934 Batter-Up #61 McNair (A's)
- Beardy: 1933 Goudey #95 Crowder (Senators)
- Mariner1: 1971 Topps #110 Mazeroski (Pirates)
- TiedGame: 1955 Topps #116 Bilko (Cardinals)
- Nathan: 1941 Play Ball #128 Appleton (White Sox)
- Matt Hickes: 1953 Bowman Color #137 Dente (White Sox)
- BA Benny: 1962 Post Cereal #181 Hal Smith (Pirates)
- Night Owl: 1962 Topps #197 Dick Hall (A's)
Now its final phase: TRADING. Want to swap something you won? Leave a comment in this post! I'll give people a few days to make any exchanges and then send out the cards.