- Games suspended by umpires (e.g., because it's 2:30AM), to be finished at a later date
- Games lost when a new reliever wild pitches in the go-ahead run (statistically, that means no batters faced)
Cleveland's Ed Glynn holds the "record" for baseball's latest such wild pitch. On September 24, 1982, he entered a resumed game in the bottom of the 18th with bases loaded and one out. His first pitch bounded away from catcher Ron Hassey and Alan Trammell scored for Detroit, ending a game that started more than 3 months earlier (box score).
As it goes with inherited runners, that game's loss went not to Ed himself, but previous pitcher Bud Anderson. It would not be the only time misfortune linked Ed and Bud; check out this autographed and annotated 1983 Fleer #408.
|1983 Fleer #408, "Ed Glynn" (Bud Anderson)|
18 innings is the longest such game I could find, but a couple dozen in baseball history fit the unfortunate story of "man meets ball, ball meets backstop, (different) man loses game."
July 20, 2011: Chicago's Chris Sale leaves runners on 1st and 3rd with two outs in the 11th. Incoming reliever Sergio Santos short-hops a slider, Alex Gorden scoots home safely, and the Royals win 2-1.
August 24, 1993: New York blows a 4-2 lead in the 9th, but utility man Jeff McKnight redeems their home half by smacking a pinch-triple and sprinting home when new reliever Kevin Wickander backstops his third pitch. Mets win 5-4.
April 10, 1980: Opening day, Rangers vs. Yankees. After both lineups fail to score in 10+ innings, Texas loads the bases in the 11th with an infield single, sacrifice, and two intentional walks. Future HOFer Rich Gossage enters, throws an un-Goose-like wild pitch, and Rangers win 1-0.
September 8, 1977: Everything in the 9th goes wrong for Chicago, who opened the inning with a 2-0 lead. Lead-off walk, error, Dave Kingman hitting something other than a homer, etc. Lerrin LaGrow enters with the bases loaded and wild pitches Anaheim to a 3-2 victory. (Echoes of Herb Washington: winning run Orlando Ramirez specialized in pinch-running and only played the field in 8 of his 25 games that year.)
June 20, 1965: This one happened in the TOP of the 9th, but sort of fits the mold. Minnesota and New York entered the inning tied 4-4. A one-out walk and single put runners at the corners, followed by this off-key pitching sequence.
- Passed Ball; Versalles Scores (Twins lead 5-4)
- Valdespino Steals 2B
- Intentional Walk
- Foul pop to catcher (Second out)
- Walk; Valdespino to 3B; Oliva to 2B
- Hal Reniff replaces Bobby Tiefenauer pitching and batting 9th
- Wild Pitch; Valdespino Scores; Oliva out at home (Twins leads 6-4)
Minnesota swept that day's doubleheader and New York added injury to insult by losing Roger Maris for 49 games to a wrist fracture in the nightcap. Hidden irony to losing by wild pitch: it was bat day at Yankee Stadium (with awesome photo from the Times blog).
September 28, 1949: Washington entered the 9th trailing Boston 1-0, but strung together three singles for a 1-1 tie. Veteran reliever Mel Parnell came on and foiled a suicide squeeze by pitching out for an easy "caught stealing" at home. Al Kozar took third as the trailing runner, a crucial detail when Parnell followed his heads-up pitching with "one that got away." Senators win 2-1; original Milwaukee Journal coverage courtesy of Google Archives.
I found those seven games with this Baseball-Reference search and sometimes lose hours to statistical rabbit holes. Similar searches include lose-by-balk or lose-by-HBP. The Red Sox finished an amazing comeback with one of the former against the Angels on July 10, 1986, more details at "Rich Gedman, a Clutch Single, and a Balk."
Any favorites that you've built at B-R.com or elsewhere?